A little more than halfway through the movie, we stopped it so that I could get some cheese (many scenes of French cooking will cause that sort of thing). My father remarked that the film was long. Actually, I told him, it's only two hours. "It seems longer," he said, "I guess that's not a good sign."
It's not really fair to put any mortal up against the greatest actress of her generation. Or, for that matter, to put any actor against the self-assured and understated Stanley Tucci. But the other main figures could have at least tried to put forth an effort that didn't go from bad (Amy Adams) to worse (Chris Messina). It's frustrating because there are situations in which Adams can act, so some of the blame must go to the script. The Julia Child segments are a delight, which only serves to highlight the unrelenting tedium of the 'story' of a blogger setting out to cook the entire Mastering the Art of French Cooking in a year. Having read parts of the book that was the result of her project, I can say that the movie strips any sense of dramatic tension, most centrally the near-nervous breakdown that prompts the project. The dialogue is wooden; the delivery is wooden; and Adams and Messina have to compete with the utter joie de vivre that Streep brings to any role. Worse, it's completely unclear what the contemporary scenes of the movie are trying to say, and when they do seem to say something the message is somewhat atrocious. The most important thing, ladies, is a good husband, good being defined as one who puts up with your bitchy behavior. "Do you really think I'm a bitch?" Julie asks her best friend. "Yes, but we all are" is the response, a revelation that led me to exclaim aloud "Ah, the feminism of Nora Ephron." In the moment where it was poised to turn Child from an icon to a human being with flaws, it reassures us that the 'real' child is, in fact, the figment of Julie's imagination. Although some of these are problems with the book itself, at least the book creates characters we can care about in the first place.
Julie and Julia is worth watching for the Child segments, but do get up and do some cooking during the rest.